Ratings
4
out of 5
6,432
user ratings
Your rating
or to rate this recipe.
Have you cooked this?
or to mark this recipe as cooked.
Private Notes
Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.
Cooking Notes
Maura
This got rave reviews tonight! *15-30 minutes isn't enough. Chicken thighs need 40 minutes to braise* I skimmed off about 1/2 of the fat after browning the thighs, since the coconut milk is so rich* I threw in some cauliflower I had in the fridge at about the 20 minute mark. I think any veg could be a nice addition, since its so rich* Next time I might use light coconut milk* I found the 1/2 tsp cinn. too much and would use just a pinch next time, but my dining companion liked it.
lee
By cooking the chicken with the top uncovered by sauce the thighs stay crispy and brown. Otherwise the skin gets rubbery. If the sauce is half way up the side the thighs definitely cook through.
PDXer
In step 1, instead of “set chicken aside,” I set it in a 375 degree preheated oven while I made the sauce. Then I simmered it for 20 minutes as per the directions. That little “boost” ensured that the thighs were cooked thoroughly.
andrew m
Was very good, but recommend flipping the chicken thighs halfway through the simmer process so they more definitively cook all the way through. I had to make that adjustment after the fact.
Lyssah
Very good recipe. To me, had a delicous savory cinnamon smell and taste. I did it all in an instant pot (rice too) and it came out perfectly. I set the instant pot to the brown rice setting (15 min on mine) and added half a cup of chicken broth for the rice. At the end, the chicken was falling apart. I let it sit on warm for an extra 20 min, and the rice thickened the sauce.
Phil F
Used boneless,skinless chicken thighs and stirred in 5 oz baby spinach at the end to make it a more complete meal. Was excellent.
diane
I followed Lyssah’s advice and used my instapot, rice and all. DIVINE. I sautéed the chicken and the onions in the pot as directed, added the liquid, 3/4 c of rice and the chicken and set it on rice, which is low, for 15 minutes. Yum! I echo the advice of others—don’t forget the lime.
Katinka
This was delicious. I used a 2-inch piece of cinnamon as I didn’t have ground and it was perfect. Another tip: Trader Joe’s has frozen chopped ginger which makes for easy prep.
Eric
So this was a rare miss for us. The chicken needs to simmer significantly longer than 20 min to cook all the way through, and the amounts of spices and garlic, and ginger need to be bumped way up to make it as flavorful as it should be. Maybe we just didn’t have a pan with the right geometry, but there was no way for us to position the chicken to where the skin wouldn’t be covered by sauce while cooking and wind up rubbery. It has potential to be a great recipe, just not working out for us.
Eric
I combined a bunch of different ideas from the notes here and this turned out amazing!Removed all the skin.Added 1 tsp curry powder and 1 Tb tomato paste with the spices.I only used 1/2 of the 13 oz can of coconut milk.Put in in the oven for 35-40 minutes at 375 instead of simmering on stove.Mixed in 1 head of cauliflower with 25-30 minutes to go.Turned out very good, but next time, I think this could be spicier and I think adding red peppers is a great idea.
Josh
Fantastic recipe. I added two red bell peppers - sliced - at the end (when you put the chicken back in). The result was reminiscent of thai curry.
Mary
I would really appreciate it if you would include the nutrition information. thanks.
mcfife
Converted all teaspoons to tablespoons on the spices and still thought more would not be wrong. Delicious!
RickMac
Followed recipe as written. Used 4 boneless/skinless chicken thighs. Very straightforward recipe and delicious results. All suggested cooking times worked well. Tossed in about a dozen halved cherry tomatoes with the can of crushed tomatoes which added a lovely textural element (as well as some punches of sweetness). Husband practically licked the plate clean, so I’m scoring this one a success.
Neda
This is just perfect. The sauce needed more time to thicken and don’t miss the lime squeeze.
Sophia Lyons
Our chicken wasn't enough for the number of people to feed so we added a can of chickpeas to stretch it -- I'll make this with just the chickpeas on no-meat nights too. Very tasty. I want to try adding 1/2 tsp curry powder.
maxG
Made this but with desiccated coconut flakes soaked in hot water then blended and strained. Way better coconut milk this way IMO. Added a branch of 15 fresh curry leaves to everything and let it cook like bay leaves in a soup, then removed before serving. Gives curry leaf flavor without a bunch of chopped up curry leaves.
Jordan
This was great, I made three minor changes. First, I removed about half the fat after browning. Second, I only used about half of the coconut milk. It was still a little rich and creamy but didn’t dull the other flavors. Finally, after I added the chicken back in the pan I popped it in the oven at 350 for about 40 minutes. Chicken was cooked through and skin was nicks and crispy,
yeeesss
Y’all are weird. Followed this exactly (but tripled red pepper flakes because spice is good) and it was SO good and cooked all the way through.
spices
Do everything you can to limit greasiness Pat dry Drain fat throughout Cool chicken through as much as possible, before putting in sauce (to preserve crispy skin)Actually, don’t cook it in the chicken fat at all, start with new oil
Loves_to_cook
So, bone in thighs take way longer than 15 minutes to cook and mine, being pasture raised and not commercially raised, were huge, even bigger than most breast. What I did was braise them slightly, otherwise kitchen fills with smoke, so one needs a good hood vent. Cook them as the recipe says, adjusting for time if thighs are huge like mine were, then take the breasts under the broiler for the finish. Otherwise the recipe is perfect.
Fern
I used a yellow onion, otherwise followed the recipe. Delicious!!
Stacey
Really yummy. I started the chicken Molly-Baz style - skin down in a cold, dry cast iron. Set pan to medium and don’t move the chicken until it releases on its own. Then move around to equal browning. Remove chicken and follow recipe as described. Added 1/2 tsp garam masala and 1/2 tsp smoky turmeric. Also added ~cup small-chopped cauliflower. Will definitely make again! Naan would be a good addition.
sma
We started without the cilantro and lime because I forgot it. When added this became a keeper. Can use skinless, boneless thighs, light coconut and maybe fresh or frozen tomatoes from my garden.
Valerie
It is really a mild curry, at least too mild to our taste, increase spices for more flavors. Pair with naans.
KB
This was a hit at my house! I read the reviews and ended up doubling the spices as people suggested, used chicken breasts instead of thighs (personal preference) and cooked in the instant pot for 15 minutes on pressure cook after I sautéed everything in the instant pot first. Will definitely make again!
fran
I followed the recipe and liked it well enough to try again with some tweaks like adding more salt, ginger, cayenne, and tomatoes - using a stronger tasting onion - and using less coconut milk. The coconut milk really dulled the flavor of the spices.
Joody
I didn't know coconut milk could break, but now I do so next time I will temper it first. Followed previous recommendations: more ginger, garlic, cumin. added tomato paste, but still light in color. added steamed cauli and thin sliced carrots to the onion saute. finished in oven for 40 minutes. delish!! will make again!
Dke
This was good, but one of the chicken thighs was pretty big and didn't get cooked all the way thru.
lindsey g.
This was a miss. The chicken was really nice - took longer than 20 minutes to braise up to temp but was good and moist with nice flavor. The “sauce” was the letdown, I think a full can of coconut milk was too much, like other commenters said. If I decided to try this again, I’d do half the coconut milk and chicken broth but I probably won’t try again. Too coconut heavy and just kind of bland-rich. I even added some fish sauce for umami but still was disappointed.
Private notes are only visible to you.